When it comes to choosing the ideal Westchester County, NY residential fence, the options can seem endless and sometimes overwhelming. That’s where we come in! As a trusted fencing contractor in New York, the pros at Campanella Fence are here to guide you through the process of making fence selection a little easier. In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of the top two selling fence products: vinyl fence and wood fence. Read on to gain a clear understanding of which option best suits your needs and preferences.

Vinyl Fencing and Wood Fencing: The Basics

Wood fences are a popular, classic, and natural choice for any home. A wood fence provides a beautiful border that can be designed to fit your needs based on your priorities and preferences. Not only do they come in a variety of styles that will suit any taste, but they are also affordable compared with some alternative fencing options. 


Vinyl fences are an increasingly popular choice for homeowners who desire a low-maintenance, attractive fencing option for their Mahopac area property. Vinyl fencing is strong and durable and comes in a variety of styles and colors to suit the look of any type of property. Made of durable PVC, vinyl fences require very little maintenance to keep them looking great. 

Let’s Compare Vinyl and Wood Fences for the Mahopac, NY Area

Both wood and vinyl fences would be a great choice for your new Westchester County, NY residential fence. They are both attractive and offer a variety of customization options. But like most things, they each have their benefits and drawbacks. As a trusted fencing contractor in New York, our experts at Campanella Fence can show you some of the things you should consider when choosing between vinyl and wood fences. 


Vinyl fences definitely offer the advantage of requiring minimal maintenance, making them a time-saving and cost-effective choice for homeowners. A simple rinse with a hose and gentle cleanser easily removes any stubborn dirt or debris. With occasional repairs for rare damages, vinyl fences remain virtually maintenance-free.


A wood fence, on the other hand, does require quite a bit more maintenance. Regular monitoring and inspections to detect any signs of cracking, rotting, or warping are all necessary to ensure your fence stays in good shape. To ensure that your wood fence will last as long as possible, routine painting or staining is necessary to prevent premature deterioration and more significant maintenance concerns down the road. Proactive maintenance is the key to keeping your wood fence beautiful and functional over time.


Wood fences offer upfront affordability in most cases, which is an advantage for most property owners. It’s important to consider, however, the recurring maintenance costs like staining and repair and the shorter longevity of a wood fence.


While vinyl fences do tend to have a higher upfront cost compared to wood, their long-term benefits far outweigh the initial cost. With minimal maintenance required and exceptional durability, a vinyl fence proves to be a cost-effective choice in the long run. 


When it comes to fencing options, vinyl offers many benefits, making it often a top choice for property owners seeking full privacy, semi-privacy, and decorative fence styles. At Campanella Fence, we proudly offer a range of vinyl fence options that cater to all different tastes and budgets. 


While vinyl fencing does provide versatility and low maintenance, wood fences are also highly customizable. As a top fencing contractor in New York, Campanella Fence offers a wide selection of wood fence styles, which allows you to personalize your fence to fit your taste and priorities.


Vinyl fencing definitely comes out on top when it comes to durability. Made of a PVC plastic composite, vinyl fencing is resistant to weather, temperature changes, and even pests. A vinyl fence can last up to 20-30 years with minimal maintenance and upkeep. As a result, vinyl fencing doesn’t require the same level of costly repair or replacement that wood does, making it a more cost-effective long-term choice.


In comparison, if left susceptible to its environment, wood fencing can warp, fade, and even rot in extreme conditions. By virtue of being a natural product, it will need to be replaced much sooner than a vinyl fence. Choosing a more durable wood will provide you with a longer-lasting option that is also more resistant to insect damage than pressure-treated pine fencing, and both should be regularly maintained with a quality stain and sealant.

The Pros and Cons of Wood and Vinyl Fences


Pros of Vinyl Fence

  • Durability: Resistant to insects, high-quality PVC resists breakdown, unlike natural materials. 
  • Ease of Maintenance: occasionally rinsing your vinyl fence with water and a gentle cleaner is usually all the maintenance required. 
Pros of Wood Fence

  • Natural Appearance: wood fences are well suited for creating a natural-looking barrier
  • Highly Customizable: with an abundance of top cuts and designs, wood fences are one of the most customizable fence options.
Cons of Vinyl Fence 

  • Upfront Cost: vinyl fences can be more expensive than wood materials initially. 
Cons of Wood Fence

  • Increased Maintenance: wood fences need regular painting or staining and potential repairs.

Campanella Fence is the Top Fencing Contractor in New York

At Campanella Fence, we are proud to offer great quality wood and vinyl fences for properties in Mahopac, New York and the surrounding area. As one of Mahopac’s finest fence companies, we pride ourselves on our excellent customer service and expert knowledge. You can take a look at some of our many clients’ projects in the photo gallery on our website and see why we are considered one of the best fencing contractors in New York.

Ready to Work With the Best Fencing Contractor in New York?

From premier wood fences to top-notch vinyl fences and so much more, the team at Campanella Fence is looking forward to helping you create the backyard you’ve been dreaming of! If you have any questions, give us a call at (845) 628-2200 or contact us online. Our team of friendly fence experts is here to help and answer any questions!